When it comes to shipping products, choosing the right packaging can make all the difference in ensuring your items arrive safely and in good condition. There are many packaging options available, but some of the most popular ones are Bubble Mailers, Poly Mailers, Corrugated Boxes, Poly Bags, and Paperboard. Each of these options has their own advantages and disadvantages, so it’s important to choose the best one for your specific needs.

Comparison Table – Bubble Mailers vs Poly Mailers vs Corrugated Boxes vs Poly Bags vs Paperboard

Bubble Mailers:

DescriptionProsConsRecommended Items
Padded envelopes with an extra layer of bubble wrap inside for protection. Can accommodate items with sharp or angled edges.Provides extra cushioning and protection for non-fragile items. Comes in a variety of sizes.Slightly bulkier and more expensive than other options.Clothing, books, small electronics.

Poly Mailers:

DescriptionProsConsRecommended Items
Lightweight polyethylene bags, suitable for non-fragile items.Cost-effective and lightweight. Available in various sizes and colors. Can be customized.Offers minimal protection compared to other options. Not suitable for fragile items.Clothing, documents, small accessories.

Corrugated Boxes:

DescriptionProsConsRecommended Items
Sturdy boxes made from wavy fluted paper. Provides maximum protection.Reliable and suitable for fragile and larger items. Different sizes and sturdiness available. Easy to brand and customize.Bulkier, requiring more storage space. Can be more expensive compared to other options.Electronics, fragile items, dinnerware.

Poly Bags:

DescriptionProsConsRecommended Items
Clear, lightweight plastic bags for non-fragile items.Affordable, easy to store, and customizable.Offers minimal protection. Not suitable for fragile items.Jewelry, small electronic parts, clothing.


DescriptionProsConsRecommended Items
Durable and stiff packaging material made from compressed layers of paper.High-quality finish, suitable for commercial purposes.Generally not suitable for heavy items or those requiring significant protection.Food packaging, gift boxes, decorative items.

Note that the “Recommended Items” column is a general suggestion for the type of items each packaging option is commonly used for. The suitability may vary depending on individual circumstances, so it’s important to assess the specific needs of your shipment.

Bubble Mailers: these are a popular option for shipping items that are not fragile but require extra protection. These mailers have an extra layer of padded protection inside the envelope, making them a great choice for items that have sharp or angled edges. The bubble wrap also helps prevent damage from external particles. Bubble Mailers are slightly bulkier and more expensive than Poly Mailers, but they are still easy to store and come in a variety of sizes that can be customized according to your needs.

Poly Mailers: a cheaper and lightweight alternative to traditional packaging options such as boxes. They are made of polyethylene bags and are a great option for items that are not too fragile and don’t need to rely on the packaging to stay protected. They are easy to store and are available in a wide range of sizes, colors, and can even be customized with your company’s logo or design.

Corrugated Boxes: a must-have for shipping fragile and/or larger items such as dinnerware. They are made from a wavy fluted paper in the middle, which adds layers and strengthens the board, making them the most reliable packaging solution available. Corrugated Boxes vary in size and sturdiness, so it’s essential to choose the right one for your specific needs. In terms of customization, Corrugated Boxes are very easy to brand and are widely used for retail packaging and display options, among other functions.

Poly Bags: a popular option for shipping items that are not very fragile but require a little extra protection. They are clear and lightweight, making them a great option for items that can be shipped together, such as jewelry or small electronic parts. They are affordable and can be easily customized to suit your needs, making them a great option for small to medium-sized businesses.

Paperboard: another packaging option that is widely used for commercial purposes. It is made from compressed layers of paper and is known for its durability and stiffness. Paperboard is often used for food packaging, gift boxes, and other decorative items that require a high-quality finish.


Choosing the right packaging for shipping your products is crucial for ensuring they arrive in good condition. Bubble Mailers, Poly Mailers, Corrugated Boxes, Poly Bags, and Paperboard are all great options to choose from, depending on the nature and fragility of your product. Take the time to evaluate your needs and choose the right packaging that’ll keep your items protected and secure during transport.

Who are we? Speed Commerce is an end-to-end provider of scalable customer experience solutions for ecommerce retailers and manufacturers. We grow our clients’ businesses by providing winning customer experience strategies such as 24/7/365 ecommerce customer service, order fulfillment, and warehousing. If you like our content and want to see other specific content, or want to learn more about how 3rd-party fulfillment can help grow your bottom line, reach out to us here.